BRITISH JOURNAL OF P SYCHIATRY ( 2 0 0 5 ) , 1 8 6 , 6 7 ^ 7 3
Charcoal-burning suicide in post-transition
Hong Kong
KATHY P. M. CHAN, PAUL S. F. YIP, JADE AU and DOMINIC T. S. LEE
KATHYP.M.CHAN,MRCPsych,Department of Psychiatry,Chinese University of Hong Kong, and Kwai Chung
Hospital,Hong Kong; PAUL S. F.YIP, PhD,Department of Statistics and Actuarial Science, and Hong Kong
Jockey Club (HKJC) Centre for Suicide Research and Prevention,University of Hong Kong; JADE AU,MPhil,
HKJCCentre for Suicide Research and Prevention,University of Hong Kong;DOMINIC T. S. LEE,MRCPsych,
MD,Department of Psychiatry,Chinese University of Hong Kong,Hong Kong, and Department of Social
Medicine,Harvard Medical School,Cambridge,Massachusetts,USA
Abstract
Background Charcoal-burning, a new
suicide method, emerged in Hong Kong
during the latest economic recession. Within
2 months charcoal-burning had become
the third most common suicide method.
Aims To examine the characteristics of
suicides by charcoal-burning, and to
delineate the pathways linking macro-level
economic and social changes with the
subjective experiences of those surviving a
charcoal-burning suicide attempt.
Method Both quantitative and
qualitative methods were used.In the
coroner’s records study, the first 160 cases
of suicide by charcoal-burning were
compared with a control group.In the
ethnographic enquiry,we interviewed 25
consecutive informants who had survived
serious suicide attempt using charcoal burning.
Results People who completed suicide
by the charcoal-burning method were
more likely to have been economically
active and physically healthy, and were less
likely to have had pre-existing mental
illness.Charcoal-burning suicide was
associated with overindebtedness.Media
reports were pivotal in linking
overindebtedness and financial troubles
with charcoal-burning.
Conclusions The political economyof
suicide by charcoal-burning illustrated
how historical, socio-economic and
culturalforces shaped the lived experience
that preceded suicide.
Declaration of interest None.
Funding detailed in Acknowledgements.
Corresponding. Dr Paul S.F.Yip,HKJCCentre for Suicide Research and Prevention,University of Hong
Kong,Hong Kong.Fax: +852 2549 7161; e-mail: sfpyip@hku.hk
|